Derivatives, Duration and Control
Swap and Treasury markets have usually crossed paths, for quite some time now, in portfolios. The demand for hedging and securing longer durations are part of the explanations. In the case of the search for greater duration for a strategy, it is possible to secure fixed rates through swaps.
When rates fall, or there is the expectation that they will fall, institutional investors with long liabilities, such as pension funds, have the pressure to extend the duration of their portfolios. To meet that pressure, they already buy additional bonds of greater duration, but it is also possible to enter into interest rate swaps as a receiver of fixed rates.
The logic of the swap consists of exchanging a floating rate in return for a fixed one. If the rate will fall, my floating-rate obligations, well, will fall. The institutional investor of course has the right to the payment that comes from a fixed-rate obligation, although rates are falling.
Let us begin.
Interest Rate Swaps (IRS), specifically an interest rate swap in a receiver modality, are used for a structural need of modern institutional management, especially for pension funds, and even more so after suffering some withdrawals in certain countries.
Duration (whether Macaulay or Modified) measures the percentage sensitivity of the price of a bond or a portfolio to variations in interest rates. The greater the duration, the greater the volatility of the portfolio in response to movements in the yield curve.
The role of the Receiver Swap (we receive fixed and pay floating), is to expand the duration of a bond portfolio, but without the need to sell the current assets or immobilize large sums of cash. The manager will use a derivatives contract (interest rate swap), agreeing to a fixed-rate receiver position. It should be kept in mind that these are contracts somewhat more complex than options, since they are OTC.
The fixed leg (what the pension fund receives) consists of periodic cash flows calculated on a predetermined fixed interest rate (e.g. 5% annually) on a determined notional amount. This flow behaves exactly the same as having a long-term sovereign or corporate bond that pays a fixed coupon. It replicates an asset with high duration (a 10-year swap has a duration close to 8-9 years).
The floating leg (what the pension fund pays) requires paying a short-term reference interest rate that is adjusted periodically (for example, SOFR, Cámara, Libor or 90-day collateral rates). Since these are short-term rates that are constantly updated, their duration is practically zero.
When this swap is incorporated into the real fixed-income portfolio (not synthetic), the balance of sensitivities is altered. Given that the fixed leg contributes a very high duration, and the floating leg subtracts an almost null duration, the net result is a drastic increase in the portfolio's duration.
A synthetic duration was created. The fund achieves the same effect as buying billions in very long-term bonds, but operating only on the notional value of the derivative and committing only guarantees (collateral and margins), and not 100% of the asset's value.
Although the massive use of interest rate derivatives has been at the center of the recent financial debate due to the global volatility of long-term yields, there are several arguments that make this operation plausible and structurally necessary for a pension fund.
Asset and liability matching. The nature of pension fund liabilities are long-term payments. They have extremely high duration. That demands a good understanding of the type of fund and this market.
The problem of the fixed-income spot market. Local and international bond markets rarely offer a sufficient supply of sovereign or corporate bonds with long maturities, to organically match liabilities.
The swap solution. Swaps allow the duration of portfolios to be artificially stretched, but especially in conservative funds or those close to withdrawal, since they allow the portfolio to become sensitive while reducing the risk of actuarial mismatch in the event of interest rate fluctuations. If the fund were exposed directly to bonds, the problem would be selling them in a context of falling rates. The latter could be more harmful than a swap.
Capital efficiency and liquidity management. The problem of going to the bond spot market is the consumption of cash and the liquidity of the funds. That can be harmful in an interest rate fluctuation. In addition, derivatives allow leverage through (i) notional amounts, (ii) daily guarantees, (iii) daily margins and (iv) without counterparty risk (I do not have to find my counterparty).
Flexibility and precision in the face of market changes. The modification of the duration of large funds is costly and slow. In fact, it can produce adverse price changes. Therefore, when one goes to the bond market, it is not possible to manage duration with great precision, but rather by segment, periods and it is never immediate. This becomes more complicated with limit regulations.
In general, institutional regulations recognize derivative operations. These instruments are usually considered, on the one hand, as hedging tools, but also, on the other hand, as investment instruments. This difference is conceptual, therefore it is possible to interchange instruments between them. The point is how it is measured, in the sense that the derivative used for investment must be accounted for as such, as an investment. The latter matters for investment guideline purposes.
Then, whether used as an investment or as a hedge, we must (i) consider a limit, the maximum exposure of the fund; (ii) ensure liquidity, to make sure that liquid assets exist in order to pay the contract flows and margin calls, so as not to abruptly interrupt the investment in the event of stress (selling under pressure); and, risk, the expected loss under volatile market conditions.
This is the instrument, which has nothing wrong with it in itself. We are dealing with contracts that allow one to navigate the market well, whether upward or downward. But it is different from the risks of fixed-income markets. It depends on how we use them.
After years without interest rates, and the revaluation of 2022, bonds were not very attractive. But fixed income is not a monolith. Understanding it well is fundamental, but very difficult.
High public debt and deficits, their magnitude, political stagnation, inflation risks, and interest rate cuts or hikes in the United States, creates an environment in which investors must study allocations.
In the last decade, households and large companies have deleveraged. Governments, on the other hand, have accumulated debt at an unprecedented speed. This has brought great volatility.
When interest rates rise, as they are now, bond prices fall. In recent years we have learned a lesson in this relationship. As interest rates rose sharply from their pandemic lows, bond prices fell, and long-term bonds generally suffered greater losses. Understandably, that experience reinforced the perception that longer-duration bonds are riskier.
But there is another aspect of the duration equation that receives much less attention, stated in Chile by Eduardo Walker in the face of the proposal for a more conservative fund in the AFPs. The impact of interest rates on the cost of financing spending.
Higher interest rates have not only reduced bond prices. They have also reduced the amount that families need today to finance their future spending.
Understanding both sides of that relationship can change the way we think about risk.
In finance, the amount required today is called the "present value" of a future expenditure. Higher rates make future expenditure less costly to finance today. Lower rates make it more expensive. And the further away the cost is, the more important this relationship becomes.
This is the key distinction. Price volatility and financial risk are not necessarily the same thing. It is useful to evaluate investments in the context of the role they are intended to play. Ultimately, investment risk is not really about how much an asset moves, but about the risk that assets and objectives become separated.

Comments